Issue-10-Boardroom-Insights_-Company-Culture.png?w=1024&h=576&scale
Category: Boardroom Insights

Issue 10: Is Your Company Culture What You Think It Is?

⏱ 5-minute read

The culture your board believes it has may not be the culture your employees experience.

The Boardroom Question

If you asked your employees to describe your company culture, would their answers match yours?

It’s an interesting question for any CEO or senior leadership team.

Most organisations have a reasonably clear idea of the culture they want to create.

They may describe themselves as collaborative, innovative, supportive, ambitious or people-focused.

These qualities often feature prominently on websites, in recruitment materials and in company values.

But there can be a difference between the culture an organisation promotes and the culture its people experience every day.

And understanding that difference is important.

Because company culture isn’t defined by what an organisation says about itself.

It’s defined by what people experience when they’re part of it.

Culture Is What Happens When Nobody Is Watching

Company values are important. They provide a framework for how an organisation wants its people to behave.

But values only become meaningful when they influence everyday decisions.

Does the organisation genuinely encourage collaboration, or are departments rewarded for protecting their own interests?

Does it promote innovation, but discourage people from taking risks?

Does it describe itself as supportive, while expecting employees to be constantly available?Company Culture

Does it celebrate openness, but react defensively when someone raises a concern?

These aren’t necessarily signs of a fundamentally unhealthy organisation.

They may simply indicate that the culture has evolved in ways the leadership team hasn’t fully recognised.

The CIPD’s guidance on organisational culture highlights the importance of looking beyond broad cultural statements and examining the everyday practices and behaviours that shape employees’ experiences. It’s a useful reminder that culture is something people live, rather than something a business simply declares.

The real culture of a business is often revealed in the small decisions and behaviours that happen every day.

The View from the Boardroom Can Be Different

Senior executives naturally experience their organisation differently from many other employees.

They have access to information, influence over decisions and opportunities to shape their working environment.

They may also have established relationships and a level of autonomy that others don’t enjoy.

As a result, what feels like an open and collaborative culture at executive level may feel quite different elsewhere.

An organisation might genuinely encourage senior managers to challenge decisions, while more junior employees feel uncomfortable questioning their immediate manager.

A CEO might believe the business offers excellent career development, while employees struggle to see opportunities beyond their current roles.

Neither perspective necessarily reflects the whole picture.

But both are important.

The challenge for boards is to understand how culture is experienced throughout the organisation, not simply how it feels around the senior table.

The Financial Reporting Council’s guidance on corporate culture reinforces the importance of boards regularly assessing and monitoring organisational culture, rather than assuming that stated values accurately reflect the experiences of employees.

Are You Hearing What People Really Think?

Employee surveys, engagement scores and feedback programmes can provide useful information.

But they don’t always tell the complete story.

People may hesitate to express concerns if they doubt their feedback will remain confidential or believe that nothing will change.

Others may simply tell senior leaders what they think they want to hear.

That makes it important to create several ways for people to share their experiences.

Regular conversations, confidential feedback, exit interviews, employee forums and meaningful contact between senior leaders and different parts of the business can all provide valuable insights.

But collecting feedback is only half the challenge.

What matters just as much is what an organisation does with it.

If people repeatedly raise concerns and see no response, they may eventually stop speaking up.

And silence shouldn’t automatically be mistaken for satisfaction.

What Gets Rewarded Becomes Your Culture

One of the clearest indicators of organisational culture is what a business chooses to recognise and reward.

Consider a company that describes teamwork as a core value.

If promotions consistently go to individuals who deliver exceptional personal results but contribute little to the wider organisation, what message does that send?

Company cultureOr a business that promotes work-life balance while celebrating those who regularly work excessive hours.

Employees quickly notice the difference between stated values and actual behaviour.

They learn what really matters by observing who succeeds, who is promoted, whose behaviour is tolerated and how difficult situations are handled.

This is particularly important at senior level.

Leadership behaviour doesn’t simply influence culture. It helps define it.

Culture Is Tested When Things Go Wrong

It’s relatively easy to demonstrate positive values when business is going well.

The real test often comes during more challenging periods.

How does the organisation respond when somebody makes a mistake?

What happens when a project fails?

How are difficult commercial decisions communicated?

Are employees treated fairly when restructuring becomes necessary?

Do senior leaders take responsibility when something goes wrong?

These moments can have a lasting impact on how people view their employer.

An organisation that responds with openness, fairness and accountability can strengthen trust even when the circumstances are difficult.

Conversely, a business that behaves inconsistently with its stated values may damage confidence that has taken years to build.

Publishing: Culture in a Creative Industry

Publishing businesses often have a strong sense of identity.

Editorial independence, creativity, relationships, intellectual curiosity and a passion for books, education or information can be important parts of their culture.

These qualities help attract people who care deeply about the industry.

But passion alone doesn’t guarantee a positive working environment.

Publishing businesses also need to balance creative ambition with commercial realities, changing technology and evolving expectations about career development and working

practices.

As organisations grow, merge or diversify, maintaining a shared culture can become more complicated.

Different imprints, divisions and functions may develop their own ways of working.

The challenge for senior leaders is to preserve what makes their organisation distinctive while ensuring that the culture continues to support the people and capabilities it needs for the future.

Financial Services: Culture Beyond Compliance

In Financial Services, organisational culture has particular significance because of its relationship with governance, conduct, risk and customer outcomes.

Policies, procedures and regulatory frameworks establish important expectations.

But culture determines how those expectations are interpreted and applied in everyday situations.

Do employees feel comfortable raising concerns?

Are commercial objectives balanced appropriately with customer interests?

Is responsible behaviour recognised?

Do leaders demonstrate the standards they expect from others?

A business can have comprehensive policies and still experience cultural problems if everyday behaviours don’t reflect them.

For boards, understanding culture therefore goes beyond employee engagement.

It is also part of understanding how effectively the organisation operates and manages risk.

Culture Can Be a Competitive Advantage

A positive and authentic company culture can make a meaningful difference to an organisation’s ability to attract and retain talented people.

When individuals consider joining a business, they’re not simply evaluating the job description and remuneration.

They’re also trying to understand what it would actually be like to work there.

How are people treated?

What is the leadership style?

Will they have opportunities to contribute and develop?

Do the organisation’s values align with their own?

And perhaps most importantly, does the reality match the promises?

This is particularly relevant when recruiting senior executives.

An appointment can look excellent on paper, but if expectations about culture and ways of working are significantly different, even a highly capable individual may struggle to succeed.

Equally, a senior leader joining an organisation brings their own expectations and behaviours, which can influence the culture around them.

Successful appointments require an understanding of both the person and the environment in which they’re expected to thrive.

Culture Isn’t Static

One of the most important things for boards to recognise is that culture changes.

New leadership, business growth, acquisitions, hybrid working, technological developments and changing employee expectations can all influence how an organisation operates.

A culture that served a business well when it employed 30 people may not work in quite the same way when it employs 300.

Likewise, a culture developed around a long-established leadership team may need to evolve as new people, markets and priorities emerge.

This doesn’t mean abandoning the organisation’s identity.

It means recognising that a healthy culture requires attention, reflection and occasional adjustment.

The objective isn’t to create a perfect culture.

It’s to create one that is authentic, effective and aligned with the organisation’s values and future direction.

Five Questions for Your Next Leadership Meeting

  1. If our employees described our culture anonymously, would their answers reflect the values we promote?
  2. Do people at different levels of the organisation experience our culture in the same way?
  3. Are the behaviours we reward and promote consistent with the values we communicate?
  4. How do we respond when employees challenge decisions, raise concerns or make mistakes?
  5. Has our culture evolved alongside our business strategy, workforce and ways of working?

These questions don’t necessarily require an extensive cultural transformation programme.

Sometimes they simply require leaders to listen more carefully and challenge their own assumptions.

Key Takeaways

  • Company culture is defined by everyday experiences and behaviours, not simply published values.
  • Senior leaders may experience organisational culture differently from other employees.
  • Feedback is valuable only when people feel safe providing it and believe it will be taken seriously.
  • What organisations reward and tolerate often reveals more about their culture than what they say.
  • Difficult situations provide important tests of leadership behaviour and organisational values.
  • An authentic culture can strengthen employee retention, recruitment and business performance.
  • Culture needs to evolve as organisations grow and change.

A Final Thought

At Mosaic Executive Search, we’ve spent more than 25 years working with organisations and senior executives across Publishing and Financial Services.

Those conversations have reinforced how important organisational culture can be when making senior appointments.

Understanding a candidate’s experience, achievements and capabilities is essential.

But understanding the organisation they’re joining — its values, leadership style, expectations and everyday working environment — is equally important.

Because successful leadership appointments aren’t simply about finding someone who can do the job.

They’re about finding someone who can succeed in the organisation, contribute positively to its culture and help shape its future.

And for boards, perhaps the most valuable starting point is recognising that the culture they intend to create and the culture people actually experience may not always be quite the same.

The strongest organisations don’t simply describe their culture. They listen, understand it and demonstrate it through their actions.


Further Reading

Boardroom Insights | Issue 08
Would Your Rising Stars Choose You?

Boardroom Insights | Issue 09
Who Dares to Disagree with the CEO?

Mosaic Search & Selection – Specialists in senior level recruitment in Publishing,and Financial Services

Share article

You may also be
interested in...

Category: Boardroom Insights

Issue 11: Just Because You Can, Does It Mean You Should?

⏱ 5-minute read Business ethics in leadership are often tested when the commercially advantageous decision isn’t necessarily the fairest one.…

Read More

Category: Boardroom Insights

Issue 9: Who Dares to Disagree with the CEO?

⏱ 5-minute read Why constructive challenge is essential to effective leadership and better boardroom decisions. The Boardroom Question When did…

Read More