Boardroom-Insights-11-Business-Ethics.png?w=1024&h=576&scale
Category: Boardroom Insights

Issue 11: Just Because You Can, Does It Mean You Should?

⏱ 5-minute read

Business ethics in leadership are often tested when the commercially advantageous decision isn’t necessarily the fairest one.

The Boardroom Question

Have you ever faced a business decision where the commercially advantageous option wasn’t necessarily the fairest one?

  • Perhaps the contract allowed you to take a particular course of action.
  • Perhaps there was no legal obligation to do anything differently.
  • Perhaps you could justify the decision from a purely financial perspective.
  • But something about it didn’t feel quite right.

These are the moments when business ethics become more than a statement on a company website.  Because doing the right thing isn’t always the same as doing what you’re legally entitled to do.  And the decisions that define an organisation’s reputation are often made when nobody is obliged to behave generously, fairly or collaboratively.

The real test of business integrity isn’t how an organisation behaves when it has to do the right thing. It’s how it behaves when it has a choice.

The Difference Between What’s Permitted and What’s Right

Contracts, policies and regulations provide essential frameworks for conducting business.

They establish responsibilities, protect interests and create clarity around commercial relationships.

But they cannot anticipate every situation or answer every question about fairness.

There will inevitably be circumstances where a business has several legitimate options available, each with different implications for its customers, employees, suppliers or commercial partners.

One option may deliver the greatest immediate financial benefit.

Another may demonstrate greater consideration for the people involved or better reflect the organisation’s stated values.

Neither decision should be taken lightly.

Good business ethics involve looking beyond what is permissible and considering what is reasonable, fair and consistent with the organisation’s principles.

This doesn’t mean businesses should ignore their commercial interests.

Profitability, financial discipline and protecting shareholder value are fundamental responsibilities.

But commercial success and ethical behaviour should not be viewed as opposing objectives.

The most respected businesses understand that sustainable success depends on both.

The Spirit of an Agreement Matters

Strong business relationships are built on clear expectations and mutual understanding.  Formal agreements play an important role, particularly when significant financial commitments or responsibilities are involved.  However, many commercial relationships also depend on trust, professional courtesy and the understanding that both parties will act reasonably.

Sometimes circumstances change.  Priorities shift, budgets are reviewed or new people become involved in decisions.  These developments can create situations that were not fully anticipated at the outset.

When that happens, the response matters.

Is the first instinct to find a technical justification for a particular position?  Or is it to have an open conversation about what was understood, what has changed and what would constitute a fair outcome?

There may not always be a straightforward answer.

But approaching a disagreement with transparency, respect and a genuine willingness to find a reasonable solution can preserve relationships that might otherwise be damaged.

The spirit in which an agreement is honoured can be just as important to a business relationship as the words in which it is written.

Recognising the Value Others Bring

Businesses rarely succeed entirely on their own.

They depend on employees, suppliers, advisers, customers, partners and professional networks.

These relationships generate value in different ways.

Sometimes that value is easily measured through products delivered, projects completed or services provided.

At other times, it may come from specialist knowledge, an introduction, an innovative idea or an opportunity that would not otherwise have arisen.

Not every contribution creates an automatic entitlement to payment or reward. Clear commercial terms remain important.

Nevertheless, recognising the contribution others have made is a hallmark of a professional and collaborative organisation.

A business that consistently acknowledges the value of its relationships is more likely to encourage goodwill and future cooperation.

And goodwill, while difficult to quantify, can be an important commercial asset.

The True Cost of Winning

Most senior executives have experienced a difficult commercial negotiation.

There may be pressure to reduce costs, protect margins or secure more favourable terms.

These are entirely legitimate business objectives.

But there is an interesting question worth considering:

Is winning a negotiation always the same as achieving the best business outcome?

A company may secure a short-term financial advantage but leave the other party feeling that the relationship has been handled unfairly.

The immediate saving may look attractive.  Yet the longer-term consequences could include reduced trust, damaged relationships, less willingness to collaborate or missed future opportunities.

Of course, businesses cannot agree to every request or make concessions simply to preserve goodwill.  Sometimes difficult decisions are necessary.  The distinction lies in how those decisions are reached, explained and implemented.  A firm but fair approach can maintain respect even when the outcome is disappointing.

A technically successful negotiation that leaves lasting resentment may ultimately prove less valuable than it first appeared.

Why Good Business Ethics Are Everyone’s Responsibility

It’s tempting to think of business ethics primarily in terms of corporate governance, compliance or board-level policy.

But ethical behaviour is demonstrated throughout an organisation.

  • It appears in how promptly invoices are paid.
  • How suppliers are treated.
  • How customers are supported when something goes wrong.
  • How employees are recognised for their contributions.
  • How difficult conversations are handled.
  • And how promises are honoured when circumstances become inconvenient.

These everyday decisions create an organisation’s reputation.  They also send powerful messages internally.

If employees see senior leaders behaving fairly and consistently, they are more likely to understand the standards expected of them.

Conversely, if commercial advantage is routinely prioritised over stated values, employees may begin to question how seriously those values are held.

Business ethics are not simply a matter of having the right policies. They’re about consistently demonstrating the right behaviours.

When Doing the Right Thing Isn’t the Easiest Option

Perhaps one of the most revealing tests of business ethics comes when acting fairly involves a degree of personal or commercial sacrifice.  There may be occasions when an organisation chooses to honour a commitment even though circumstances have changed.  When it acknowledges another party’s contribution despite having no explicit obligation to do so.

Or when it considers the interests of customers, employees or other stakeholders, even if doing so makes a decision more complicated.  These choices aren’t always easy.  And they shouldn’t be confused with simply giving in or failing to protect the business.

Rather, they reflect an understanding that successful organisations operate within a wider network of relationships and responsibilities.  Sometimes doing the right thing requires a difficult conversation, a compromise or a willingness to accept a less immediately advantageous outcome.  But those decisions can also demonstrate the qualities that encourage people to trust an organisation and want to work with it again.

Integrity often becomes most visible when it comes at a cost.

Why Business Ethics in Leadership Matter

An organisation’s ethical reputation is influenced significantly by the decisions made at the top.

Senior leaders establish expectations not only through what they say, but through what they choose to do.

When faced with a difficult decision, do they consider the wider implications?

Do they encourage colleagues to challenge a proposed course of action?

Are they willing to acknowledge when a decision could have been handled better?

Do they apply the same standards to themselves that they expect from others?

These behaviours matter because employees notice them.

A leadership team that consistently demonstrates fairness, transparency and accountability helps create an environment where ethical considerations become part of everyday decision-making.

And that can be particularly valuable when employees encounter situations for which there is no obvious rule or straightforward answer.

Five Questions for Your Next Leadership Meeting

  1. When making commercial decisions, do we consider what is fair as well as what is legally or contractually permissible?
  2. Are we consistent in how we treat customers, employees, suppliers and professional partners?
  3. Could a short-term commercial advantage undermine a valuable long-term relationship?
  4. Do our employees feel confident questioning a decision they believe may be unfair or inconsistent with our values?
  5. Would we be comfortable explaining our decision, and the reasoning behind it, to everyone affected?

These questions are not designed to make business decisions unnecessarily complicated.

They’re intended to encourage the kind of thoughtful judgement that builds confidence and trust.

Key Takeaways

  • Legal and contractual compliance are essential, but they do not resolve every ethical question.
  • Fairness, transparency and respect help strengthen long-term commercial relationships.
  • Recognising the contribution of others encourages trust and collaboration.
  • Short-term financial advantages should be considered alongside potential longer-term consequences.
  • Ethical responsibilities extend to customers, employees, suppliers and other stakeholders.
  • Integrity is often demonstrated most clearly when doing the right thing requires a difficult decision.
  • Senior leaders establish standards through their everyday decisions and behaviour.
  • Strong business ethics and commercial success can reinforce one another.

A Final Thought

At Mosaic Executive Search, we’ve spent more than 25 years building relationships with organisations and senior executives.  Over that time, we’ve come to appreciate that successful business relationships depend on much more than commercial agreements.

They require trust, mutual respect, honest communication and a willingness to recognise the interests of everyone involved.  Not every business decision will be straightforward.  There will be occasions when commercial priorities differ, expectations need to be clarified or difficult conversations are unavoidable.   But the way those situations are approached can make a lasting difference.

Because a reputation for fairness and integrity isn’t created by a single statement of values.  It’s built through the decisions an organisation makes, particularly when there is no obligation to take the easier, more generous or more collaborative approach.

The strongest business relationships aren’t built on winning every negotiation. They’re built on knowing that everyone involved will be treated fairly.


Further Reading

Boardroom Insights | Issue 09
Who Dares to Disagree with the CEO?

Boardroom Insights | Issue 10
Is Your Company Culture What You Think It Is?

Mosaic Search & Selection – Specialists in senior level recruitment in Publishing,and Financial Services

Share article

You may also be
interested in...

Category: Boardroom Insights

Issue 10: Is Your Company Culture What You Think It Is?

⏱ 5-minute read The culture your board believes it has may not be the culture your employees experience. The Boardroom…

Read More

Category: Boardroom Insights

Issue 9: Who Dares to Disagree with the CEO?

⏱ 5-minute read Why constructive challenge is essential to effective leadership and better boardroom decisions. The Boardroom Question When did…

Read More